Readers: 0 | Updated: 07-19

The CIA Asks to Keep a Former Employee's Name Secret...It's Revealed In the Press...And Then...

Translate Into:
The Office of the Director of National Intelligence has sent a letter to the New York Times, protesting the paper's naming of a former CIA anti-terrorism interrogator. The CIA had objected to revealing of the man's name, but the Times decided to go ahead anyway. There was a case a while back in which many on the left became very upset about the revelation of a CIA employee's name. So far, that does not seem to be happening in this case. In any event, this is the letter from the Office of the Director of National Intelligence to the Times: In late June, The Times ran a story about a former Central Intelligence Agency interrogator who, in the words of its public editor, "used shrewd psychology, not rough stuff, to get Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the mastermind of the 9/11 attacks, to talk" ("Weighing the Risk," Clark Hoyt, July 6, 2008). The Times published the interrogator's name over the objections of his lawyers and the CIA, who fear for his safety. In supporting this decision, The Times' public editor invoked "the public's right to know." But this was a conclusion, not a premise. Unfortunately neither The Times nor its public editor has examined this asserted public interest with the same appetite they displayed for examining and discounting the interrogator's interest in his own safety. So let's correct the balance. The public editor cited two reasons to publish the name. First, the reporter said that "using the name was necessary for credibility." Really? Great stories are often told using pseudonyms, and The Times frequently withholds attributions from its stories. It generally does so for good reasons that its readers understand. What The Times may have meant is that by using the man's real name, the story would be a better read. I doubt it. But if so, The Times was weighing the man's safety against a literary interest, not the public interest. The second asserted reason for publishing the man's real name, tossed off in the last sentence of the public editor's four-column piece, was to avoid hobbling news organizations "when trying to tell the public about some of the government's most important and controversial actions." This is nonsense. The Times was going to tell the public about these interrogations whether the interrogator's name was used or not. On the other side of the balance, the public editor cited the case of another interrogator who, when his name was made public, suffered more than a dozen death threats, had his house put under police guard, and was told to take his family out of the country till the affair blew over. In the public editor's own words, he also "lost his job with a major accounting firm because executives expressed fear that Al Qaeda could attack its offices to get him ..." These are substantial prices to pay for outing an identity. By publishing this interrogator's real name, The Times put him at risk for similar treatment - and worse. Journalists face difficult decisions every day about the prudence of publishing private information. But in this case the decision to out the individual had nothing to do with the media's responsibility to inform the public about important government policies or actions. The Times also trivialized the risk to the man by putting him to the impossible burden of showing with near certainty that he would be harmed. This was morally confused. This man and many others like him undertake difficult, dangerous, and lawful missions on behalf of their country, and they deserve better from The Times.


From The Blogs

Onemanbandwidth: An American Professor in China

04-23
The Former American Professor in China
As many of you know, Iam no longer teaching. Neither time nor patience have seemed to be on my side these days. When I began to find myself challenged by students and their lack of cultural sensitivit... 查看全文

Joke of the Day

03-22
The CIA had an opening for an assassin.
The CIA had an opening for an assassin. After all of the background checks, interviews, and testing were done there were three finalists — two men and one woman. For the final test, the CIA agents too... 查看全文

Think Progress

04-22
Former high-ranking DOJ official implicated in Abramoff case.
The AP reports that a Robert Coughlin, former deputy chief of staff of the Justice Departments criminal division, was accused Monday of criminal conflict of interest in the latest case stemming from t... 查看全文

YeinJee » Asian Pop Culture

04-22
Former Korean president, farmer, tourist attraction
Former South Korean president Roh Moo-hyu has become the talk of the town with his after retirement lifestyle. His official website has become a hit with throngs of daily visitors reading his latest u... 查看全文

Boing Boing

04-23
2001 profile of "Bill Ayers, unrepentant former Weather Underground revolutionary"
Now that former Weather Undergrounder Bill Ayers is back in the news, this 2001 Slate profile of him is worth reading. He comes off as an extremely unsavory character.Much of what Ayers self-intereste... 查看全文

Boing Boing

04-23
2001 profile of "Bill Ayers, unrepentant former Weather Underground revolutionary"
Now that former Weather Undergrounder Bill Ayers is back in the news, this 2001 Slate profile of him is worth reading. He comes off as an extremely unsavory character.Much of what Ayers self-intereste... 查看全文

Danwei - Media, Advertising, and Urban Life in China

03-24
Beijing — former Haidian District head charged with graft
Beijing TimesMarch 21, 2008 Two officials busted for graft The top headline is about former head of Beijing's Haidian District Zhou Liangluo (周良洛), who was charged with taking bribes. He has allegedly... 查看全文

b5media Science and Health Channel Feed

03-25
Former Phils. President Cory Aquino Has Colon Cancer [Cancer Commentary]
Corazon C. Aquino - former (and first woman) President of the Philippines, has colon cancer. The condition of Mrs. Aquino (fondly called Cory) was recently revealed by her family. Former president Cor... 查看全文

Think Progress

03-26
Former Romney/NRCC aide joins Freedom’s Watch.
The Caucus reports: The conservative group, Freedom’s Watch, which has endured some prominent staff departures in recent months, announced today the hiring of Carl Forti, who was most recently politic... 查看全文

b5media Science and Health Channel Feed

03-26
Former Phils. Pres. Cory Aquino, On First Round of Chemo [Cancer Commentary]
I already mentioned here that Mrs. Cory Aquino has cancer of the colonas reported by her family on Monday. Although the cancers stage was not disclosed, Mrs. Aquino underwent her first round of chemot... 查看全文
More Articles