Readers: 19 | Updated: 10-02

The Candidates on Technology: A Stark Choice

Translate Into:
Take heed: The following has nothing to do with crowdsourcing, but I think you'll find it worth your while anyway. My Wired colleague, Nick Thompson, has written an essay for Washington Monthly about McCain's and Obama's respective track records on technology in general, and Internet access in particular. As usual, technology has been given short shrift in the current election cycle. (Though at least it's not a punchline, as it was in 2000.) This is understandable, what with the economic apocalypse looming and all, but a shame nonetheless. The next administration will wrestle with some of the most complex, urgent technological issues of our time, including net neutrality and the innovation lag in the United States. So for a moment, forget the bailout, forget Palin and forget about Iraq. Most of you reading this care deeply about technology, the Internet and the future of innovation. As Thompson points out in his piece, the US has fallen from fifth in the world to twenty-second in broadband penetration. We pay more for slower access. Why? "The real reason things went wrong is that we haven't regulated our telecom markets properly," writes Thompson. And that, he continues, "is where John McCain comes in."The problem is primarily the lack of competition among Internet providers. In most places, you have, at best, two choices—the local cable company or the local phone company. And these behemoths know that they don’t have to worry about new competitors. With the government’s help, they spent decades digging up roads and building lines into everyone’s home, creating an infrastructure that no start-up can replicate. Now they sit, fat and happy, neglecting customer service and innovating about as much each year as Google does each Tuesday. None of this is to say John McCain is wrong in general (Ed's Note: But he is!), or to proffer an endorsement of Obama (Ed's Note: We'll be making that one later), only to point out that McCain's zealous adherence to a deregulate-at-all-costs philosophy has ill-served his country. By forcibly yanking the teeth out of the 1996 Telecommunications Act, McCain blocked the entry of smaller, more nimble competitors to the big Telecos, and goes a long way toward explaining why we receive such horrible customer service from our cell phone carriers and ISPs. McCain’s mistakes derive partly from a lack of technological curiosity (he doesn’t use e-mail) and the presence of all sorts of Bell guys around him. His campaign manager, deputy campaign manager, Senate chief of staff, and chief political adviser have all worked as lobbyists for Verizon or AT&T.Obama, by contrast, has presented a comprehensive and, for a politician, surprisingly sophisticated technology plan, including proposing the creation of a national CTO. Maybe we can convince Mayor-for-Life Mike Bloomberg to drop his bid for perpetual autocracy over New York and apply?


From The Blogs

Parenting & Pregnancy

05-22
Is a Live In Nanny a Spot On Choice for You?
As is the case with many parents today, you and your spouse may feel as if you are spinning constantly. Between work and home you may collapse at the end of each and every day exhausted. Because of th... 查看全文

2007
PAKISTAN'S DEMOCRACY America's stark choice
By Sandy Berger and Bruce RiedelPublished: October 9, 2007  With the staged re-election on Saturday of President Pervez Musharraf, America faces a stark choice: Do we support democracy and the rule of... 查看全文

Articles about Condoms and Safe Sex Resources

08-28
Video Doctor Helps HIV Patients
I am a self-diagnosed hypochondriac. You name a disease, I am sure I have it. Any new health alerts that pop up on MSNBC are voraciously read to scan for any weird symptoms that might match up to anyt... 查看全文

Socyberty

2007
School of Choice
Years ago, I favored the school of choice's concept since I lived in a city that had a very low score in education. The idea was very appealing to me. I would live where I can afford, and my child wou... 查看全文

Success from the Nest

04-10
Success is a Choice
When it comes down to it, its all up to you. You can start the day doing something you love, spring out of bed, and be ready to go. Or you can keep trudging along. Jason Kotecki does an amazing job of... 查看全文

Business - Channel Feed

11-17
Should You Start a Business After Retirement? You May Have No Choice
In response to my post last week about “Should you start a business after retirement?“  Charlie from Circledog commented, “You may have no choice.”  He’s right.No Retirement Income. Most of us (with a... 查看全文

Personal Growth, Career Planning

04-13
Giving up Is Another Choice
Life does need cost. The life you chosed is either good or bad, but never without cost.What is Opportunity Cost? It is an important economic concept, which is defined as getting something at the expen... 查看全文

The Simple Dollar

05-18
Making the Hard Choice
When I think back over my life, Ive found that time and time again, the hard choices Ive made were the ones that provided lasting positive change in my life.When I took the easy road, it didnt have an... 查看全文

Business - Channel Feed

10-24
Vote for Slacker Manager for the Bloggers Choice Awards
Slacker Manager was nominated for the Blogger’s Choice Awards by Meredith in the Best Business Blog category. Thanks Meredith! If you like Slacker Manager, please click on the image above and vote for... 查看全文

Think Progress

04-22
UGA faculty incensed at choice of Clarence Thomas as graduation speaker.
University of Georgia faculty are concerned that having Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas as this years graduation speaker sends the wrong message after a year of sexual harassment scandals on cam... 查看全文
More Articles