Readers: 64 | Updated: 03-19

McCain Conflates Shiite Iran And Sunni Al Qaeda, Needs To Be Corrected By Lieberman

Translate Into:

li3.jpg Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) has spent a majority of his presidential campaign trying to convince voters that he is the most qualified to tackle foreign policy issues:

I would believe that my knowledge and experience and background clearly indicates that if the phone rang in the White House and I was the one to answer it, I would be the one to best address a national security crisis. [3/3/08]

I have the most experience of any presidential candidate when it comes to foreign policy and advancing our national and economic security priorities around the globe. [1/29/08]

On matters of war and peace, I offer Americans my experience, my personal familiarity with the tragedy of war, [and] deep involvement in all of the national security issues of the last two decades… [11/18/07]

Of course, McCain’s supposed prescient understanding of foreign policy has been proven faulty over and over. Today, as the Washington Post’s Cameron Barr and Michael Shear report, McCain further undermined his claim to be the best qualified on matters of foreign policy, when he repeated a mistaken claim that Iran was training al Qaeda fighters:

Speaking to reporters in Amman, the Jordanian capital, McCain said he and two Senate colleagues traveling with him continue to be concerned about Iranian operatives “taking al-Qaeda into Iran, training them and sending them back.”

Pressed to elaborate, McCain said it was “common knowledge and has been reported in the media that al-Qaeda is going back into Iran and receiving training and are coming back into Iraq from Iran, that’s well known. And it’s unfortunate.” A few moments later, Sen. Joseph Lieberman, standing just behind McCain, stepped forward and whispered in the presidential candidate’s ear. McCain then said: “I’m sorry, the Iranians are training extremists, not al-Qaeda.”

He made the same assertion on right-wing Hugh Hewitt’s radio show last night. Listen here:

Screenshot

The “common knowledge” McCain cites is simply false. Far from working together, Iran and al Qaeda represent opposing sides in the Iraq civil war. Al Qaeda is a Sunni Muslim extremist group, while Iran is ruled by Shiites, where they make up 90 percent of the population.

McCain, the so-called foreign policy expert, is confusing reports that Iran was aiding Shiite insurgents in Iraq — one of the groups that virulently opposes al Qaeda. Even some aspects of those reports have been disputed.

Considering he had to correct McCain himself, does Lieberman still insist that McCain is “almost always right on the big issues in foreign policy”?

(HT: Matthew Yglesias)

Digg It!



From The Blogs

The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan

03-06
Iraq, Iran, China
Fallows worries about the neocon position on China:    The same people -- same individuals, same organizations, same publications, same blog sites - that ginned up a war with Iraq, and that have suppo... 查看全文

The New York Review of Books

07-17
Iran: The Threat
By Thomas PowersAt a moment of serious challenge, battered by two wars, ballooning debt, and a faltering economy, the United States appears to have lost its capacity to think clearly. Consider what pa... 查看全文

Britannica Blog

09-22
Time is Running Out Before Iran Has the Bomb
As he prepares to address the UN General Assembly tomorrow, Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad (right) has returned to one of his favorite passions – Jew baiting. On September 18, 2008, he told rep... 查看全文

Britannica Blog

09-13
Iran’s Pursuit of “Street Cred”: A Reply from Riyadh
[The following, from Pulitzer Prize-winning correspondent Caryle Murphy, is in reply to Josh Xiongs post on Irans Pursuit of Street Cred and Barbara Slavins response to Xiong.] RIYADH, Saudi ArabiaIra... 查看全文

Global Voices Online

09-14
Iran:”Eternal Iranian islands of Persian Gulf”
Kourosh Ziabari, an Iran based blogger, writes that the Persian Gulf and its islands have been under the absolute administration of Iran from the ancient times. He adds UAE’s claims to Abu Musa and th... 查看全文

Global Voices Online

09-14
Iran:Persian Translation of Iranian Blog Study Now Available
Berkman Center for Internet and Society in Harvard has made its study about Iranian blogosphere available in Persian. You can now read Mapping Iran’s Online Public: Politics and Culture in the Persian... 查看全文

Global Voices Online

09-14
Iran:The Blogging Revolution
Antony Loewenstein’s The Blogging Revolution will be available on Amazon soon. The Blogging Revolution talks about Iran, Egypt,Syria,Saudi Arabia, China and Cuba. This is how he describes the book. 查看全文

Japan Probe

09-15
Iran condemns Japan as ‘pro-US stooge’
Indonesia will soon be ending its term as a non-permanent member of the UN Security Council, opening a slot reserved for an Asian country.Japan is aiming for the position, and so is Iran: Mohamed Khaz... 查看全文

Crooks and Liars

09-17
No Cause For War In New Iran Report
The International Atomic Energy Agency has just produced its latest report on Irans nuclear program. (Full report here in PDF, leaked by US officials as usual.) Mainstream media outlets are going with... 查看全文

Global Voices Online

09-19
Iran: An important Shi'a server was hacked
Javanrood, an Iranian blogger, says[Fa] the most important Shia server was hacked by Group-xp, a Wahabite group. Several high ranked clerics sites have been hacked too. 查看全文
More Articles